Newcastle United 0-1 Borussia Dortmund: Felix Nmecha seals visitors’ win
25 October 2023
Newcastle United suffered the first defeat of their Champions League campaign as Borussia Dortmund secured a vital victory on a rain-soaked night at St James' Park.
Eddie Howe's side started their return to Europe's elite competition in impressive fashion with a draw against AC Milan in San Siro before a memorable thrashing of Paris St-Germain on Tyneside.
Newcastle, however, could not rediscover that same intensity while Dortmund belied their status as Group F's bottom side prior to the game with an impressive display and secured victory through Felix Nmecha's composed finish in first-half added time.
Howe's side had their chances though, with Dortmund keeper Gregor Kobel thwarting Anthony Gordon twice and saving brilliantly from substitute Callum Wilson after the break.
They also came desperately close to claiming a point in the closing stages when Wilson's header hit the bar and Gordon's shot was deflected on to the frame of the goal with seconds remaining.
Dortmund kept Newcastle keeper Nick Pope busy too, particularly with an outstanding double save from Donyell Malen and Niclas Fullkrug in the first half.
The result has turned this group into a tense and tight one, with Newcastle hoping for better fortune in their next game in Dortmund next month.
Newcastle falter in a deluge
Newcastle's drenched players trooped off disconsolate at the final whistle, a sharp contrast to their elation at the end of the magnificent 4-1 win against PSG in their last home Champions League game.
They did not perform badly. They simply did not meet the same standard of the night against the French side, helped by a fast start and an intensity that stunned PSG. They were also up against a streetwise Dortmund side boasting experience as well as energy.
Dortmund were far more dangerous and composed than PSG, dealing comfortably with the Tyneside atmosphere and giving their own noisy supporters plenty to cheer.
Newcastle were also disrupted by an early injury to striker Alexander Isak, although Wilson was dangerous when he came on and could easily have got on the scoresheet.
Howe will also point to cruel luck and curse the woodwork at the end, but overall Newcastle had a learning experience.
No need for Newcastle panic
The defeat is unquestionably a setback for Newcastle, especially as they knew another win here would leave them sitting pretty in Group F and locked firmly on course for the Champions League knockout stage.
But Howe will not be panicking after one loss, and nor should he.
They now sit level on points with Borussia Dortmund but in third place in the group, which serves to increase the importance of their return match in Germany.
Newcastle have certainly made life tougher for themselves with the fixtures to come but they are right in the fight to reach the last 16, even if there will have been an immediate post-match feeling that this was a chance that got away.
Player of the match
SchlotterbeckNico Schlotterbeck
with an average of 7.18
Newcastle United
Squad number22Player namePope
Average rating6.08
Squad number10Player nameGordon
Average rating5.83
Squad number8Player nameTonali
Average rating5.53
Squad number13Player nameTargett
Average rating5.51
Squad number2Player nameTrippier
Average rating5.46
Squad number5Player nameSchär
Average rating5.45
Squad number9Player nameWilson
Average rating5.35
Squad number6Player nameLascelles
Average rating5.20
Squad number39Player nameBruno Guimarães
Average rating5.18
Squad number33Player nameBurn
Average rating5.16
Squad number24Player nameAlmirón
Average rating5.14
Squad number28Player nameWillock
Average rating5.10
Squad number36Player nameS Longstaff
Average rating5.00
Squad number23Player nameMurphy
Average rating4.96
Squad number7Player nameJoelinton
Average rating4.89
Squad number14Player nameIsak
Average rating4.88
Borussia Dortmund
Squad number4Player nameSchlotterbeck
Average rating7.18
Squad number11Player nameReus
Average rating7.02
Squad number8Player nameNmecha
Average rating6.99
Squad number21Player nameMalen
Average rating6.91
Squad number1Player nameKobel
Average rating6.90
Squad number5Player nameBensebaïni
Average rating6.88
Squad number20Player nameSabitzer
Average rating6.84
Squad number14Player nameFüllkrug
Average rating6.78
Squad number15Player nameHummels
Average rating6.74
Squad number7Player nameReyna
Average rating6.70
Squad number17Player nameWolf
Average rating6.68
Squad number27Player nameAdeyemi
Average rating6.55
Squad number23Player nameCan
Average rating6.55
Squad number25Player nameSüle
Average rating6.27
Squad number9Player nameHaller
Average rating6.25
Squad number6Player nameÖzcan
Average rating6.25
Line-ups
Newcastle
Formation 4-3-3
- 22Pope
- 2Trippier
- 6Lascelles
- 5Schär
- 33BurnSubstituted forTargettat 70'minutes
- 36S LongstaffSubstituted forTonaliat 65'minutes
- 39Bruno GuimarãesBooked at 79mins
- 7JoelintonSubstituted forMurphyat 65'minutesSubstituted forWillockat 70'minutes
- 24Almirón
- 14IsakSubstituted forWilsonat 15'minutes
- 10Gordon
Substitutes
- 1Dúbravka
- 3Dummett
- 8Tonali
- 9Wilson
- 13Targett
- 18Karius
- 20Hall
- 21Livramento
- 23Murphy
- 28Willock
B Dortmund
Formation 4-3-3
- 1Kobel
- 17WolfBooked at 35mins
- 15Hummels
- 4Schlotterbeck
- 5Bensebaïni
- 20Sabitzer
- 23CanSubstituted forÖzcanat 43'minutes
- 8NmechaSubstituted forReynaat 79'minutes
- 21MalenSubstituted forSüleat 78'minutes
- 14FüllkrugSubstituted forHallerat 79'minutes
- 11ReusSubstituted forAdeyemiat 63'minutes
Substitutes
- 6Özcan
- 7Reyna
- 9Haller
- 18Moukoko
- 25Süle
- 27Adeyemi
- 33Meyer
- 35Lotka
- 42Blank
- 43Bynoe-Gittens
- Referee:
- Artur Manuel Soares Dias
- Attendance:
- 52,024
Match Stats
Live Text
Post update
This news item was provided by the BBC Sport - Football website - the original link is: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67209904?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=KARANGA